Public justice on thieves in the City of Lilongwe: An observation by Burnett Munthali


While walking through town, I encountered a disturbing scene at Kafoteka Minibus Depot in Lilongwe. A sizable crowd had gathered, and at the center of the commotion were two young men lying face down in the mud. The crowd’s murmurs and the situation indicated that these individuals were suspected of phone theft. As I observed, it became clear that their immediate fate was to be handed over to the police for further action.

Moral Lessons from the Incident

Firstly, the incident highlights the importance of adhering to the rule of law and ensuring that due process is followed. While public frustration with crime is understandable, justice should be administered through legal channels. Vigilantism undermines the justice system and can lead to wrongful punishment and escalation of violence.

Secondly, this event underscores the need for communities to act responsibly when dealing with suspected criminals. Rather than resorting to public shaming or violence, communities should support lawful procedures and cooperate with law enforcement to address crime effectively.

Thirdly, regardless of the accusations, it is crucial to respect the dignity of individuals. Public humiliation and physical abuse do not align with human rights standards and can exacerbate societal tensions. Respecting individuals’ dignity even when they are suspected of crimes is a fundamental principle of justice.

Fourthly, the role of the police is pivotal in maintaining order and ensuring justice. The incident illustrates the need for efficient and impartial law enforcement to handle criminal cases. Ensuring that suspects are treated fairly and that investigations are conducted thoroughly is essential for maintaining public trust in the justice system.

Fifthly, the reaction to this incident also points to a need for effective crime prevention strategies. Addressing the root causes of crime, such as poverty and unemployment, and implementing community-based programs can help reduce the incidence of theft and other crimes.

In conclusion, while the incident at Kafoteka Minibus Depot reflects significant public concern about crime, it also serves as a reminder of the importance of upholding legal standards, respecting human dignity, and supporting effective law enforcement. These moral lessons are essential for fostering a just and orderly society.